The New York Times recently published a provocative guest essay by Noah Shachtman, questioning the future of horse racing. The piece, titled "Dead Athletes. Empty Stands. Why Are We Paying Billions to Keep This Sport Alive?", argues that governments should cease financial support for an industry in decline. The author, a seasoned journalist with contributions to Wired and former editor-in-chief roles at Rolling Stone and The Daily Beast, highlights the shift from horse racing's heyday when it was a significant revenue generator for states. Now, as its popularity wanes, Shachtman contends that public funds should not prop up a sport marred by safety concerns and dwindling fan interest. However, advocates like Light Up Racing counter that the industry has made strides in safety and economic contribution.
Controversial Critique of Horse Racing in the New York Times
In a scathing critique published on Friday, the New York Times featured a lengthy guest essay by Noah Shachtman that delved into the contentious issue of government support for horse racing. During the golden era of racing, tracks generated substantial tax revenues for state governments, serving as one of the few legal gambling outlets outside Las Vegas. However, as other forms of gambling have emerged—casinos, lotteries, and sports betting—the relationship between racing and the government has reversed. Today, rather than supporting the state, the industry relies heavily on public subsidies and casino revenues to sustain itself.
Shachtman's essay, which spans over 4,600 words, scrutinizes the arguments used by the racing industry to justify its existence, particularly focusing on the safety of racehorses. He points to alarming statistics, such as the reported deaths of 11,000 horses at American racetracks since 2014, emphasizing the ethical concerns surrounding the sport. The author also highlights the tragic breakdown of New York Thunder during the Allen Jerkens Memorial Stakes in 2023, where veterinary records revealed multiple red flags prior to the incident. Despite acknowledging improvements in safety measures under the Horseracing Integrity and Safety Authority (HISA), Shachtman remains unconvinced that these changes are sufficient.
However, advocacy groups like Light Up Racing argue that the article paints an incomplete picture. They point out the industry's significant tax contributions, record-breaking audiences at events like the Kentucky Derby, and substantial investments in track infrastructure. Moreover, they highlight a 27% reduction in racehorse fatalities since HISA's implementation, suggesting that the sport is moving in the right direction. The group stresses the importance of challenging misinformation and advocating for continued progress.
Additionally, Shachtman touches on the working conditions of backstretch workers, who often labor long hours for minimum wage. While recognizing efforts by prominent figures in the industry to improve these conditions, he suggests that more needs to be done. Yet, the essay largely overlooks positive developments, focusing instead on a binary argument that calls for the sport to stand on its own or face obsolescence.
From a broader perspective, this debate underscores the complex interplay between tradition, ethics, and economics in modern society. As sports betting expands across the United States, the question arises: should public resources continue to support a sport that struggles to retain fans and faces ongoing safety challenges? The Times' coverage, while critical, invites readers to consider whether horse racing can adapt to contemporary standards or if its time has passed.
As a reader, this article prompts reflection on the balance between preserving cultural traditions and addressing pressing societal needs. It raises important questions about the role of government in supporting industries that may no longer align with public interests. Ultimately, it challenges us to think critically about the future of horse racing and whether it can evolve to meet modern expectations.
In a significant day of training for some of horse racing's elite, several graded-stakes winners completed workouts on Friday morning. The session provided valuable insights into the form and fitness of these champions as they prepare for upcoming races. Notable performances included Vahva, Carson’s Run, Gaming, and others, each showcasing impressive times at various distances across different tracks. These workouts highlight the rigorous preparation and competitive spirit that define top-tier horse racing.
Vahva Shines in Keeneland Workout; Other Top Horses Also Impress
In the crisp autumn air, Keeneland played host to an array of stellar performances by seasoned racehorses. Among them was Vahva, the 5-year-old daughter of Gun Runner, who breezed three furlongs in a swift 36.8 seconds under the watchful eye of trainer Cherie DeVaux. This time placed her third fastest among nine horses working the same distance. It marked Vahva’s second workout since her eighth-place finish in the Breeders’ Cup Filly & Mare Sprint. Earlier this year, she claimed victories in the Derby City Distaff (G3) and Chicago (G3), and placed third in the Ballerina (G1).
Elsewhere, Carson’s Run, a Grade 1 winner, clocked an impressive 38.4 seconds over three furlongs at Payson Park. Trainer Christophe Clement’s charge had previously finished fifth in the Hollywood Derby (G1). Gaming, another Grade 1 victor, posted the fastest six-furlong time of 1:11.8 at Santa Anita, while Trikari worked four furlongs in 50.3 seconds at Palm Meadows, continuing its preparation following a sixth-place finish in the Bryan Station (G3).
Skippylongstocking, a three-time Grade 2 winner, turned in a solid 48.9-second effort over four furlongs at Palm Meadows, while Mystic Lake, a two-time Grade 2 winner, made her first post-race appearance with a 37.5-second run over three furlongs. Dicey Mo Chara, Verstappen, Whatmakessammyrun, Skelly, Another Mystery, Artislas, Batten Down, Taking Candy, Where’s My Ring, and Wild Bout Hilary also recorded noteworthy times across various tracks, demonstrating their readiness for future challenges.
These workouts underscore the intense preparation and dedication required to compete at the highest levels of horse racing. Each performance offers trainers and owners critical data to fine-tune their strategies and ensure their horses are in peak condition for upcoming events.
From a journalist’s perspective, these workouts not only provide a glimpse into the meticulous preparation behind each race but also highlight the resilience and athleticism of these magnificent animals. The dedication of trainers and jockeys is evident in every stride, reminding us of the rich tradition and excitement that horse racing continues to offer. As these champions gear up for their next appearances, fans can look forward to thrilling performances that showcase the very best in equine sport.
Several promising thoroughbreds demonstrated their potential with strong performances during Friday's morning workouts. Among these, Gaming, under the guidance of renowned trainer Bob Baffert, showcased impressive speed. Covering six furlongs in just 1:11.8, Gaming achieved the fastest time among four horses at this distance. This workout marked his second since finishing eighth in the Southwest Stakes (G3) at Oaklawn, where he was the second favorite behind Speed King. Despite this recent setback, Gaming remains a contender, currently priced at 35-1 odds for future bets at Caesars Sportsbook in Las Vegas.
In addition to Gaming, two other notable horses also made significant strides on Friday. Filoso, trained by Chad Summers, clocked an impressive 47.9 seconds over four furlongs at Palm Meadows. This time placed him eighth out of 40 horses working at the same distance. His previous performance included a sixth-place finish in the Kentucky Jockey Club (G2) at Churchill Downs. Meanwhile, He’s Not Joking, under the care of Josie Carroll, completed five furlongs in 1:00.7 at Palm Meadows, ranking eighth out of 17 horses at that distance. His last race saw him place fifth in the Holy Bull (G3) at Gulfstream Park.
The dedication and hard work of these equine athletes and their trainers are evident in their consistent performances. Each horse is preparing diligently for upcoming races, aiming to prove their mettle on the track. The competitive spirit and relentless pursuit of excellence in the world of horse racing inspire fans and participants alike, highlighting the sport's rich tradition and unwavering commitment to excellence.